Nickelo's Pizza

If you're looking for a cozy spot with great food in Milan, IN, Nickelo's Pizza is a local favorite that should be on your radar. Nestled at 530 N Warpath Dr, this pizza joint offers more than just a quick meal. Whether you're in the mood for a delicious pizza, a hearty hoagie, or a refreshing drink, Nickelo's Pizza delivers in both flavor and atmosphere.

Menu Highlights: A Delicious Range of Options

At Nickelo's Pizza, the menu is designed to cater to all kinds of tastes. Their pizza is the star of the show, with various toppings that include favorites like all meat, deluxe, and vegetarian options. If you're not in the mood for pizza, try one of their mouthwatering hoagies such as the Steak, Ham & Cheese, or Chicken Salad. For those looking for something lighter, the Chicken or Fish Hoagies offer a great alternative.

The drink selection is also diverse, featuring Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew, Root Beer, and Sierra Mist. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or hanging out with friends, these drinks pair perfectly with your meal.

Services That Cater to Every Need

Nickelo's Pizza is all about convenience, offering a variety of services that make dining here stress-free. If you’re in a hurry, take advantage of their takeout service or have your meal delivered right to your door. For those who prefer dining in, the restaurant provides outdoor seating—ideal for enjoying a meal in the fresh air.

Families and groups will appreciate the quiet atmosphere, making it a great spot for gathering with loved ones or friends. The restaurant also features a private parking lot and free Wi-Fi, so you can stay connected or simply relax. Nickelo's Pizza also offers catering for special events, and alcohol is available to complement your meal.

What People Are Saying

Reviews from satisfied customers reflect the restaurant’s commitment to both quality food and great service. For example, Sophia P. shares that Nickelo's Pizza offers "good prices for even better food" and is a perfect spot to visit with friends. Matt B. also speaks highly of the pizza, noting that it’s "really good pizza at this place, and at a good price also." He also mentions the daily specials, which add extra value to the experience.

While some diners have noted the restaurant's 50s diner decor, the food itself clearly makes up for any aesthetic shortcomings. Matt B. highlights the irresistible aroma of the meat pizza, which even led him to try it before leaving.

Unique Atmosphere and Dining Experience

At Nickelo's Pizza, you’ll experience a unique blend of friendly service and a relaxed dining environment. The establishment strikes a balance between offering comfort food in a casual, unpretentious setting while providing excellent customer service. Whether you’re coming for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a group outing, Nickelo's Pizza provides the perfect space to enjoy your meal.